Skip to content

Star-Crossed Lovers: Thoughts on The Fault In Our Stars

(Via Wikipedia)

The Fault In Our Stars (2012)

By John Green

So I’m a little late to the John Green party, but it’s better late than never. I read this book last summer when the film was just released in theaters (and yes, I have watched the movie too).

The Fault in Our Stars is about a sixteen year-old girl with thyroid cancer, Hazel Grace Lancaster, who is forced by her mother to attend a support group for cancer kids. At one of the meetings, she befriends a seventeen year-old boy named Augustus Waters, who lost his leg due to osteosarcoma. The two bond over a novel entitled, An Imperial Affliction, by Peter van Houten, which results in Augustus surprising Hazel to a trip to Amsterdam to meet the author. 

It is obvious from the title, even before reading this novel, that it is going to be a tragedy. Although it appears that the symbols, stars and lovers, suggest romance, the relationship between the two convey a nuance of sadness and misfortune. The “fault” in our stars refers to something problematical in their relationship, or fate bringing the two lovers together for a short period of time, and then separating them. The Fault in Our Stars also alludes to other well-known tales such as William Shakespeare’s “star-crossed lovers,” Romeo and Juliet or the famous Chinese folktale, “The Weaver Girl and the Cowherd.” According to legend, the two lovers, Orihime and Hikoboshi (respectively represented by the stars Vega and Altair) are separated by the Milky Way, and are only allowed to meet once a year—the seventh day of the seventh lunar month—when the stars, Vega and Altair, are under the same sky and are able to see each other.

Now, I found Peter van Houten’s character amusing. He is an eccentric, but also an arrogant and rude alcoholic writer. I think that the film’s portrayal of him (Williem Dafoe as Peter van Houten) was spot on: he was exactly what I pictured him to be. In fact during the film, I was smirking at the part when Peter van Houten played Swedish hip-hop music when meeting Hazel and Augustus.

Aside from Peter van Houten, I thought Augustus and Hazel’s characters and the development of their relationship is realistically portrayed. While reading, there were many jokes and adorable moments between the two; in which makes the reader feel as if he or she were also there, sharing the moment with them. Although Augustus Waters is a self-proclaimed virgin and he never had a serious relationship before Hazel, I honestly think he has more game than we, as readers, give him credit for. In fact, I think that Augustus’ sudden interest in Hazel’s favorite book, An Imperial Affliction, and also the trip to Amsterdam, was his game plan to “put the moves on” Hazel Grace Lancaster. Thus, I conclude that Augustus Waters could be seen as a ladies’ man.

One of the main dilemmas for Hazel and Augustus is figuring out the actual ending of An Imperial Affliction. As I read, I kept wondering why was it so important for Hazel and Augustus to have an “actual” ending to the book which ends with a mid-sentence. Well, from Hazel and Augustus’ perspective, they do not have enough time to actually live their lives due to their illnesses. Henceforth, they desire for the main protagonist of An Imperial Affliction to be guaranteed a “decent ending (life),” because Hazel and Augustus won’t have one.

I think the mid-sentence ending of that novel is a perfect metaphor for life. Some of our life goals and wishes are stability and solutions to our problems. At times, we wish for a fortune-teller to predict our futures: we all hope to live a good life; in which when once we are at our deathbeds, we can reflect on our lives and actually smile. Yet in reality, it doesn’t work that way. We can’t predict the future, but instead we hope and pray in the back of our minds that “everything will turn out okay in the end.” Since we can’t predict our futures, we read books and watch films because those characters have endings, and those endings are usually idealistic and meet our expectations about what our lives should be like. As for Hazel, it annoys her that her favorite book, An Imperial Affliction, has no actual ending. There is no guarantee or reassurance that the main character will live a “good life,” which I ironically thought is an appropriate ending because that is how life actually is.


6 thoughts on “Star-Crossed Lovers: Thoughts on The Fault In Our Stars Leave a comment

  1. The title also refers to a quote from Shakespeare’s Julius Caesar; “The fault, dear Brutus, is not in our stars, / But in ourselves, that we are underlings.”.

    John Green is saying the opposite of Shakespeare because life just isn’t like that. Sometimes, things just happen that aren’t anyone’s fault.

    Liked by 1 person

  2. I’m also a big fan of John Green, his youtube channel vlogborthers and mentalfloss, check them out if you haven’t. So when all the hype came around, I also picked up the book, although I was disappointed by the book, it didn’t feel right and also I’m not a big fan of the romance genre.

    You have given a nice explanation of the mid sentence ending of the book here.

    Liked by 1 person

    • Thanks for reading! 🙂

      I haven’t heard of his youtube channel, but I’ll check it out sometime. I am curious on what you mean by “it didn’t feel right.” And it is understandable, I know many people who don’t like the romance genre (but I enjoy it, so it’s okay 🙂 ).

      Did you read the book, “Paper Towns”? Are you considering on watching the movie and writing a review on it? I haven’t, and not sure I am going to. I have no interest in watching the movie, but it would be an interesting read from you.

      Liked by 1 person

      • I am currently reading paper towns and plan to watch the movie also. After Bourne identity there has been some time when I have analysed a movie and the book from which it was adapted.

        By didn’t feel right I meant that the whole book was based upon cancer patients falling in love and then one of them dying in the end. Death was always implied in the book and then before picking up the book itself I had read reviews that the book made them cry or they were in tears at the finals pages whereas the end for me was something that I knew from the beginning. John Green’s brilliance was there in the writing like there is in his vlogs, but the whole story wasn’t just for me.

        Liked by 1 person

      • Yeah, I also had the impression that someone is going to die at the end. For me, the storyline was alright. It wasn’t a real tearjerker.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: